The holiday season is approaching fast. Thanksgiving dinner, Black Friday chaos, Christmas celebrations, New Year's countdowns, Hanukkah candles. Your employees want to be home with family. Your customers want your business open.
Here's the reality: most frontline workers would rather be anywhere but at work during major holidays. Yet retail stores, restaurants, healthcare facilities, and service businesses need staff on the floor. The solution? Holiday pay that makes showing up worth their while.
But holiday pay gets complicated when you add overtime rules, religious accommodations, and the fiscal reality of paying premium wages during your busiest season. Let's break down what managers actually need to know.
What Federal Law Says About Holiday Pay
Here's something that surprises many business owners: federal law doesn't require holiday pay at all.
According to the U.S. Department of Labor, "The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) does not require payment for time not worked, such as vacations or holidays (federal or otherwise). These benefits are generally a matter of agreement between an employer and an employee (or the employee's representative)".
Read that again. There's no federal mandate that you pay employees extra for working Thanksgiving or Christmas.
So why do so many businesses offer it? Because the market demands it. Try staffing a restaurant on Christmas Day without offering premium pay. Good luck with that.
When Holiday Pay Meets Overtime
Here's where things get tricky. Holiday pay and overtime are two different calculations, and managers often confuse them.
Overtime is legally required. The FLSA requires that covered nonexempt employees receive "at least time and one-half the regular rate of pay for all hours worked over 40 in a workweek". If your employee works 45 hours during a week that includes Thanksgiving, they're entitled to time-and-a-half for those extra 5 hours.
Holiday pay is voluntary. You choose whether to offer time-and-a-half, double time, or any premium for working a holiday itself. But once you promise it, you need to deliver it.
Here's an example that trips up managers constantly:
Your employee works their regular 40-hour week, which includes 8 hours on Thanksgiving Day. You offer time-and-a-half for holiday work. Many managers think this means the employee gets 48 hours of pay (40 regular + 8 overtime).
Wrong. The employee gets 44 hours of pay: 40 hours regular + 4 hours holiday premium. The holiday premium is calculated on top of their regular rate, not added to their total hours for overtime purposes.
Now let's say that same employee works 48 hours during Thanksgiving week. They get:
- 40 hours at regular rate
- 8 hours at overtime (time-and-a-half)
- Plus whatever holiday premium you've promised for the Thanksgiving Day hours
This is why scheduling software that can track both overtime thresholds and holiday rates becomes essential during the holiday season. Calculating this manually across 15-30 employees? That's how payroll errors happen.
The Religious Accommodation Requirement
Remember how federal law doesn't require holiday pay? There's a catch that affects holiday scheduling: religious discrimination laws.
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act requires employers to "reasonably accommodate" employees' religious practices unless doing so creates an undue hardship. As the Texas Workforce Commission notes, this means "an employer may not treat employees or applicants more or less favorably because of their religious beliefs or practices".
This matters during the holidays because many major celebrations have religious significance. Christmas, Hanukkah, Eid, Diwali. An employee who observes these holidays has legal protection to request time off.
What counts as "reasonable accommodation"? Generally:
- Flexible scheduling that allows time off for religious observance
- Shift swaps between employees
- Voluntary shift substitutions
- Modified work schedules
What you can't do:
- Refuse all requests for religious holiday time off without attempting accommodation
- Penalize employees for taking religious holidays
- Create a hostile environment around religious practices
- Force someone to work a religiously significant holiday when alternatives exist
The practical reality: if you have 20 employees and 5 request Christmas off for religious reasons, you need to make a good faith effort to accommodate them. Saying "we're too busy" isn't enough. You need to explore options like hiring seasonal workers, offering shift swaps, or adjusting hours.
But here's what managers miss: you also can't give preferential treatment based on religion. If you automatically approve Christmas requests but deny Hanukkah requests, you're discriminating. Holiday scheduling policies need to apply consistently across all religious observances.
How to Approach Holiday Staffing
The biggest mistake managers make during the holiday season? Assuming their regular scheduling approach will work.
It won't.
Start planning in October. By the time Thanksgiving week arrives, you should already know:
- Minimum staffing needs for each holiday
- Who's willing to work which holidays (surveyed in advance)
- Your budget for holiday premium pay
- Backup plans for no-shows
Ask your team about holiday preferences early. Some employees actually prefer working holidays. They're not religious observers of that particular day, or they have family obligations they'd rather avoid, or they want the extra money. Others will quit before missing Christmas dinner with their kids.
A simple survey in October can reveal this. "Which holidays are you willing to work? Which holidays are you unable to work for religious or family reasons?" Give people the chance to self-select.
Rotate holiday shifts fairly. If you run this right, nobody works every major holiday. Create a rotation where employees who work Thanksgiving get priority for Christmas off. Those who work Christmas Eve get New Year's Eve off. Make the rotation visible and consistent.
Offer genuine incentives. Remember, federal law doesn't require holiday pay. But your competition might offer it. Consider:
- Time-and-a-half for all holiday hours
- Double time for major holidays like Thanksgiving and Christmas
- Guaranteed holiday premium plus first choice of January schedule
- Bonus shifts during slower periods for those who cover holidays
The math matters here. Paying time-and-a-half on Thanksgiving Day costs you 50% more in wages. But losing your experienced staff because they're burned out or feel taken advantage of? That costs you way more in turnover, training, and lost productivity.
Hire seasonal help. Holiday staffing shouldn't fall entirely on your core team. Bring in temporary workers specifically for the holiday rush. They can take some of the burden off your regular employees and give you more scheduling flexibility.
Managing Overtime During the Holiday Season
Holiday weeks create perfect conditions for accidental overtime. Your busiest days fall in the same week. Employees pick up extra shifts to cover for others. Someone calls out and you need last-minute coverage. Suddenly your labor costs spike.
Here's how to keep overtime in check without burning out your team:
Track hours daily, not weekly. Don't wait until Friday to realize someone hit 42 hours on Wednesday. Use scheduling software that shows real-time hour totals and alerts you when employees approach 40 hours.
Build in buffer zones. If your full-time employees normally work 38-40 hours, keep them at 35-37 during holiday weeks. This gives you room to handle unexpected absences without triggering overtime.
Cross-train aggressively. The employee who can only work register can't help when your kitchen is short-staffed. Cross-training means you have more flexibility to shift people between roles without calling in someone who's already at 40 hours.
Use part-timers strategically. Your part-time employees who normally work 15-20 hours per week? They can absorb extra shifts during holiday weeks without hitting overtime. This is cheaper than paying time-and-a-half to your full-timers.
Approve overtime when it's worth it. Sometimes overtime makes financial sense. If you're slammed on Black Friday and your experienced cashier offers to stay an extra 3 hours, the time-and-a-half rate is probably cheaper than the lost sales from long lines. Just make sure you're choosing this consciously, not discovering it accidentally on payday.
Set clear overtime policies. Employees need to know: Can they pick up extra shifts freely? Do they need manager approval? What happens if they go over 40 hours without permission? Put this in writing before the holiday rush starts.
Making It Work for Staff, Customers, and Your Budget
The holiday season tests every frontline business. You need enough staff to handle increased customer volume. You need happy employees who don't feel exploited. You need to keep labor costs under control.
Here's the framework that works:
Start with your non-negotiables. What are your minimum staffing levels for each holiday? Be realistic. Thanksgiving Day at a restaurant needs more staff than a random Tuesday, but probably fewer than a regular Saturday night. Lock in those numbers first.
Calculate your labor budget. Add up your holiday premium costs, likely overtime hours, and seasonal hiring expenses. Does this work with your projected revenue? If not, you need to adjust your schedule or your pricing before the holidays hit.
Communicate expectations clearly. Your team should know by early November:
- Which holidays the business will be open
- Holiday pay rates
- How holiday requests will be handled
- Overtime policies for holiday weeks
- Scheduling deadlines
Create a coverage incentive system. Instead of begging people to pick up holiday shifts, make it attractive:
- First dibs on January schedule requests for those who work Thanksgiving
- Guaranteed two consecutive days off after working a major holiday
- Holiday bonuses paid in December for those who covered the full season
- Extra break time on holiday shifts
Monitor and adjust in real-time. Don't wait until Christmas to realize your Thanksgiving approach didn't work. Check in with your team after each holiday. Was staffing adequate? Did anyone feel overworked? Are your costs tracking with your budget? Fix problems before they repeat.
Respect people's limits. Some employees will work every holiday for the money. Others can't or won't. Both responses are legitimate. The managers who succeed during the holidays are the ones who accept this reality and plan accordingly, rather than fighting it or creating resentment.
The Compliance Checklist
Before the holiday season starts, verify you have:
Overtime tracking that accounts for:
- All hours worked across all locations (if applicable)
- Accurate regular rates for overtime calculations
- Proper exempt vs. nonexempt classifications
Holiday pay policies that specify:
- Which holidays qualify for premium pay
- What the premium rate is (time-and-a-half, double time, etc.)
- Whether holiday premium stacks with overtime premium
- How holiday pay works for part-time vs. full-time employees
Religious accommodation procedures including:
- How employees request religious holiday time off
- Your process for evaluating accommodation requests
- Documentation of your good faith efforts to accommodate
- Consistent application across all religious observances
Scheduling transparency giving employees:
- Advance notice of holiday schedules (check state laws - some require 14 days)
- Clear deadline for requesting holiday time off
- Written confirmation of approved/denied requests
- Explanation of how coverage will work
Payroll accuracy confirming:
- Correct application of holiday premium rates
- Accurate overtime calculations
- Proper documentation of all hours worked
- Timely payment (some states have specific rules for holiday pay timing)
What This Looks Like in Practice
Let's walk through a real scenario. You manage a small restaurant with 15 employees. You're open on Thanksgiving Day from 11am-7pm for a special holiday menu.
Your planning timeline:
Early October: Send survey asking who's willing to work Thanksgiving, who needs it off for religious reasons, and who's flexible. Offer time-and-a-half for all Thanksgiving hours.
Mid-October: Receive responses. Eight people want the day off. Five are willing to work. Two are flexible. You need six people to operate.
Late October: Create the Thanksgiving schedule using your five willing workers plus one flexible person who agreed when you offered them first choice of the Christmas schedule. Guarantee them all Sunday off (they usually work Sundays).
Early November: Post the final schedule. Send individual confirmations to everyone working Thanksgiving. Remind them of the time-and-a-half rate.
Week of Thanksgiving: Monitor total hours for your Thanksgiving crew. If anyone's approaching 40 hours before Thanksgiving Day, adjust their other shifts down to avoid overtime stacking on top of holiday premium.
Thanksgiving Day: Staff shows up. Service runs smoothly because people volunteered rather than being forced. You pay time-and-a-half for those 8 hours, which costs you 50% more than a regular shift, but it's baked into your holiday pricing.
After Thanksgiving: Thank your Thanksgiving crew publicly. Give them their promised Sunday off. Lock in their preferred Christmas schedules as agreed.
Result: You stayed open on a major holiday. Your staff didn't mutiny. Your labor costs were high but predictable. Customers got their holiday meal. Everyone knew exactly what to expect.
That's what good holiday planning looks like.
The Bottom Line
Holiday pay isn't legally required, but it's practically essential for most frontline businesses. Overtime is legally required, period. Religious accommodations are legally required. Keeping all three straight while running your business during the busiest season of the year takes planning.
Start early. Communicate clearly. Pay fairly. Respect people's boundaries. Track your hours carefully. Follow through on your promises.
The businesses that nail the holiday season are the ones that treat it like the operational challenge it is, not the afterthought it isn't. Your employees notice whether you planned ahead or scrambled at the last minute. Your budget reflects whether you tracked overtime or discovered it on payday. Your customers can tell if your staff wanted to be there or felt trapped.
Do the work now. Make November and December easier for everyone.
‍
