You need to tell your best server she's been rude to customers. Your line cook keeps showing up 20 minutes late. Two employees are feuding and it's affecting the whole team. Someone has to be let go.
These conversations keep managers awake at night. They're uncomfortable. They risk conflict. They might end in tears or anger. So managers avoid them, hoping the problem will resolve itself.
It won't.
The difficult conversations you avoid don't disappear. They fester. Performance issues compound. Bad behavior becomes normalized. Team morale tanks because everyone sees that nothing happens when someone screws up.
Here's what experienced managers know: difficult conversations get easier with practice. There's a structure to them. There are phrases that work. There are mistakes you can avoid.
Let's talk about how to handle the conversations you've been putting off.
Why Frontline Managers Avoid Difficult Conversations
Before we get into the how, let's address the why. Understanding why you avoid these conversations helps you push past the resistance.
You don't want to be the bad guy. You work alongside your team every day. You see them struggling, hear about their personal lives, maybe even consider some of them friends. Calling out their performance feels like betrayal.
You're worried about their reaction. What if they cry? What if they get defensive? What if they quit on the spot during your busiest shift? The fear of the unknown reaction is often worse than the conversation itself.
You lack confidence in what to say. You know something needs to be addressed, but you're not sure how to phrase it. You're worried you'll say the wrong thing, escalate the situation, or make it worse.
You hope the problem will fix itself. Maybe they're going through something temporary. Maybe they'll figure it out on their own. Maybe if you just mention it casually one more time, they'll get the message.
You're conflict-averse by nature. Some people are wired to avoid confrontation. The physical discomfort of a tense conversation feels unbearable. You'd rather absorb the problem yourself than create conflict.
Here's the reality: every single one of these fears is legitimate. Difficult conversations are uncomfortable. People do sometimes react badly. You might say the wrong thing. The person might quit.
But avoiding the conversation creates bigger problems than having it. Your top performers notice when you don't address issues. They wonder why they're working hard when others coast. They start to resent you. Eventually, they leave.
The difficult conversation you avoid today becomes three difficult conversations next month.
The Framework That Works
Most managers fail at difficult conversations because they wing it. They walk into the conversation anxious and unprepared, stumble through their points, and walk out feeling like they made everything worse.
Successful difficult conversations follow a structure. Here it is:
Prepare specifically. Don't have the conversation when you're angry. Wait until you can be calm and factual. Write down:
- The specific behavior or issue you need to address
- Concrete examples with dates and details
- The impact of this behavior on the team or business
- What you need to change
Notice what's not on this list: your feelings about the person, their intentions, or vague generalizations. "You have a bad attitude" is not specific. "Yesterday you rolled your eyes when I asked you to clean the prep station, and last week you told a customer you were too busy to help them" is specific.
Choose the right time and place. Private conversations stay private. Don't pull someone aside during a rush or in front of other employees. Schedule 15-30 minutes in a private space. Give them a heads up that you need to talk, but don't tell them it's serious or they'll spiral with anxiety. "Hey, can we chat in my office after your shift? Just want to check in about some things" works fine.
Start with the specific issue. Skip the small talk. Don't open with "How are things going?" or try to soften the blow with compliments. Be direct.
"I need to talk with you about your punctuality. You've been 20 minutes late three times in the past two weeks - Tuesday the 5th, Friday the 8th, and Monday the 11th. When you're late, we're short-staffed during our morning rush and your coworkers have to cover for you."
See what happened there? Specific behavior. Specific examples. Specific impact. No emotion. No judgment. Just facts.
Let them respond. After you state the issue, stop talking. The silence will feel uncomfortable. Resist the urge to fill it. Give them space to process and respond.
They might have a legitimate explanation. They might get defensive. They might acknowledge the problem immediately. You won't know until you listen.
Focus on future behavior. The past is done. The conversation needs to establish what happens next.
"Going forward, I need you here at 8am when your shift starts. If something comes up and you're going to be late, text me at least an hour before your shift. Can you commit to that?"
Get a clear yes or no. Don't accept "I'll try" or "I'll do my best." You need commitment to a specific change.
Document the conversation. After they leave, write down what you discussed, what was agreed to, and when you'll follow up. This doesn't need to be formal unless it's a serious performance issue that could lead to termination. But having notes protects you later if they claim the conversation never happened or they didn't understand the expectations.
Specific Scenarios and How to Handle Them
Let's get into the actual conversations managers need to have. Here are the most common ones, with scripts you can adapt.
The Performance Problem
The situation: An employee who used to perform well is now making mistakes, missing details, or producing lower quality work.
What not to do: "You've been making a lot of mistakes lately. What's going on?"
This puts them on the defensive immediately. It's vague. It sounds like an accusation.
What to do: "I've noticed some changes in your work over the past few weeks, and I want to talk about it. Last Tuesday you forgot to lock the back door at closing. On Thursday you gave a customer the wrong change twice. Yesterday you left the grill on overnight. This isn't like you, and I'm concerned because these are safety and accuracy issues. Can you help me understand what's happening?"
You've given specific examples. You've named the impact. You've opened the door for them to explain without assuming you know why.
Their potential responses and your follow-up:
If they say they're distracted by personal issues: "I appreciate you telling me. I understand personal stuff affects work sometimes. What do you need from me to help you get back on track? Do you need adjusted hours? A few days off? Because I need to know these kinds of mistakes won't continue."
If they get defensive or deny it: "I'm not trying to attack you. These are things that happened, and I have the dates right here. My job is to make sure we're running safely and efficiently. I need your help to fix this."
If they acknowledge it and apologize: "I appreciate that. Let's talk about how we prevent these issues going forward. What can you do differently? What support do you need from me?"
The Behavioral Issue
The situation: An employee is creating a negative environment. They're rude to customers, dismissive of coworkers, or resistant to feedback.
What not to do: "You need to fix your attitude."
Attitude is subjective and impossible to measure. This conversation goes nowhere because they don't know what you actually want them to change.
What to do: "I need to talk with you about how you're interacting with the team. Yesterday when Sarah asked for help during the dinner rush, you said 'that's not my job' and walked away. Last week when I asked you to restock the supplies, you sighed loudly and muttered something under your breath. This morning you were short with a customer who asked about our specials. These behaviors create tension and make it harder for us to work together. It needs to change."
Specific behaviors. Observable actions. Clear impact.
Follow-up: "Here's what I need to see instead. When a coworker asks for help, I need you to either help them or politely explain why you can't at that moment and offer an alternative. When I give you a task, I need you to acknowledge it professionally even if you're frustrated. With customers, I need patience and friendliness even when you're having a hard day. Can you do that?"
The Scheduling Conflict
The situation: An employee keeps asking for schedule changes, trading shifts, or calling out. It's disrupting operations.
What not to do: "You can't keep doing this. It's not fair to everyone else."
This sounds like a parent scolding a child. It doesn't address the root issue or establish clear boundaries.
What to do: "Let's talk about your schedule. You've requested changes four times in the past three weeks and called out twice. I understand things come up, but the frequent changes are making it hard to maintain consistent staffing. I need to understand what's driving this pattern. Is there something about your current schedule that's not working? Do you need different base hours?"
You're opening a dialogue about the underlying issue. Maybe their availability has changed. Maybe they're dealing with childcare problems. Maybe they're just unreliable and you need to know that too.
If they have a legitimate ongoing conflict: "Okay, I understand you need to pick up your daughter from daycare at 3pm on Tuesdays and Thursdays. Let's adjust your base schedule to reflect that. But I need you to commit to the adjusted schedule and minimize last-minute changes."
If they don't have a good reason: "I hear you saying there's no specific pattern, just that things come up. Here's the challenge - I need employees I can count on to work their scheduled shifts. Going forward, you get one emergency shift change per month. After that, if you need to change your schedule, you need to find your own coverage and get my approval 48 hours in advance. If you call out without being genuinely sick or having an emergency, we'll need to have a more serious conversation about your reliability."
The Termination Conversation
The situation: You've addressed issues before and nothing has changed, or the employee did something serious enough to warrant immediate termination.
What not to do: Drag it out. Apologize excessively. Over-explain. Give false hope.
What to do: "I need to let you know that we're ending your employment today. This is your last shift."
Stop. Wait for them to process. Then briefly explain why.
"We've talked twice before about your punctuality - once on September 15th and again on October 3rd. You agreed both times to arrive on time, but you've been late six more times since then. I've given you clear expectations and opportunities to improve, and that hasn't happened. I'm going to need your keys and any other company property."
Stay calm and factual. They might get angry, cry, or try to argue. Don't engage in debate.
"I understand you're upset, but the decision is final. You'll receive your final paycheck according to state law. If you have questions about that, here's the HR contact information."
Have a witness present. If possible, have another manager or supervisor in the room during terminations. This protects you from false claims about what was said.
Be prepared for them to leave immediately. Have their final paperwork ready. Know your state's requirements for final pay. Don't let them linger or create a scene in front of other employees.
The Conflict Between Team Members
The situation: Two employees are fighting, creating tension that affects everyone.
What not to do: Pick sides, try to mediate by hearing both stories separately and delivering messages back and forth, or ignore it hoping they'll work it out.
What to do: Bring them together.
"I've asked you both to meet with me because there's clearly tension between you two, and it's affecting the team. I'm not interested in figuring out who started what or who's right. I need you both to be professional with each other while you're here. That means no snide comments, no excluding each other, no talking about each other to coworkers. You don't have to be friends, but you do have to work together. Can you both commit to that?"
If they try to explain their side: "I appreciate that you both have your perspectives. But my concern is how you interact at work. Save the personal issues for outside work. Here at work, you're professionals and I need professional behavior."
If the conflict continues after this conversation, you address each person individually about their specific unprofessional behaviors using the behavioral issue script above.
The Emotional Employee
The situation: You need to give critical feedback and they start crying or getting visibly emotional.
What not to do: Panic. Backtrack. Soften your message so much it becomes meaningless.
What to do: Pause. Acknowledge the emotion without apologizing for having the conversation.
"I can see this is upsetting for you. Take a minute if you need to."
Offer tissues. Wait for them to compose themselves a bit. Then continue.
"I know this is hard to hear. I'm not trying to upset you, but these are things we need to address."
Don't rush through your points just to end their discomfort. If they're crying, they're probably not fully processing what you're saying anyway. It's okay to pause the conversation.
"Why don't you take five minutes, get some water, and come back when you're ready to finish this conversation."
When they return: "Okay, let's talk about what needs to happen next."
The key is treating their emotion with respect without letting it derail the conversation. You can be kind while still being direct.
What to Say (and Not Say)
Certain phrases make difficult conversations easier. Others make them worse. Here's your word-choice cheat sheet.
Use these:
"I've noticed..." "Specifically..." "Going forward, I need..." "Can you commit to that?" "Help me understand..." "Here's the impact..."
Avoid these:
"You always..." (rarely true and puts them on the defensive) "You never..." (same problem) "Everyone thinks..." (now they're wondering who's talking about them) "I feel like..." (your feelings aren't the point - their behavior is) "Just..." (minimizes the seriousness) "Don't take this personally" (too late, they already are)
Replace judgment with observation:
Don't say: "You're lazy." Say: "You've left your closing tasks incomplete three times this week."
Don't say: "You have a bad attitude." Say: "When I gave you feedback yesterday, you responded with sarcasm and walked away."
Don't say: "You're unreliable." Say: "You've called out four times in the past three weeks without advance notice."
See the pattern? Describe what they did, not who they are.
The Follow-Up That Actually Matters
Most managers think the difficult conversation is over when the employee walks out of the office. Wrong. The follow-up is where you find out if anything actually changed.
Set a specific check-in date. Don't leave it vague. "Let's touch base in a couple weeks" becomes never. "I'll check in with you next Monday at 2pm to see how things are going" gives you both a deadline.
Recognize improvement immediately. If they show up on time for a week straight after you addressed their tardiness, acknowledge it. "Hey, I noticed you've been punctual all week. I appreciate the effort." This reinforces that you actually care about improvement, not just catching them doing things wrong.
Address backsliding quickly. If they slip back into the old behavior, don't wait for it to become a pattern again. "I need to talk with you. You were 15 minutes late today. We just discussed this last week. What happened?"
Document everything. Keep notes on follow-up conversations, improvements, and setbacks. If the issue escalates to formal discipline or termination, you need a paper trail showing you gave them clear expectations and opportunities to improve.
When to Loop in Your Boss or HR
Some conversations are above your pay grade. Know when to escalate.
Get help when:
- The issue involves potential discrimination or harassment
- The employee threatens violence or makes you feel unsafe
- You're considering termination and want to protect against wrongful termination claims
- The employee's behavior seems related to a potential disability or medical condition
- You're unsure if the behavior warrants formal discipline
- The employee is asking for accommodations related to religion, disability, or family obligations
- Your gut says this is bigger than a typical performance conversation
Don't wait until you've mishandled it. "Hey, I need to address [situation] with [employee]. Can we talk through the right approach?" prevents problems. "I already told them [thing you shouldn't have said] and now they're threatening to sue" is harder to fix.
The Mistakes That Make Things Worse
Let's talk about what kills difficult conversations, because these errors are common and completely avoidable.
Having the conversation when you're angry. Your employee screwed up again and you're furious. You pull them aside immediately and unload. Now they're focused on your anger, not the actual issue. They leave feeling attacked, not corrected. Wait until you're calm.
Making it public. You call out someone's behavior in front of customers or coworkers. Congratulations - you've just humiliated them and destroyed any chance they'll actually hear your feedback. They're too busy feeling embarrassed and resentful. Private conversations stay private.
Letting the conversation wander. You start talking about their punctuality and somehow end up listing every mistake they've made in the past six months. Now they're overwhelmed and defensive. Stick to one issue per conversation unless multiple issues are clearly connected.
Not listening. You've decided what the problem is and what the solution is before they open their mouth. You talk at them instead of with them. Maybe there's context you're missing. Maybe they have a solution you haven't considered. You won't know if you don't listen.
Apologizing for having standards. "I'm sorry, but I need to talk to you about..." Stop apologizing. You're the manager. You're supposed to address issues. "I need to talk to you about..." works fine.
Giving feedback sandwiched between compliments. The "compliment sandwich" method is popular, although it may teach employees to ignore your praise because they're just waiting for the criticism to land. Be direct as much as possible.
Ending without clarity. The conversation wraps up and the employee leaves with no idea what they're supposed to do differently. "Just do better" isn't actionable. "Show up at 8am for your scheduled shifts" is actionable.
Building Your Confidence
If you've avoided difficult conversations for months or years, having your first one feels terrifying. Here's how to build your confidence:
Start with lower-stakes conversations. You don't have to begin with terminations. Start with small corrections. "Hey, I noticed you didn't refill the napkin holders at closing. Can you make sure that's on your checklist?" Small conversations build the muscle for bigger ones.
Write out what you'll say. You don't need to memorize a script, but writing out your key points helps you organize your thoughts. Focus on:
- The specific issue
- 2-3 concrete examples
- The impact
- What needs to change
Role-play with another manager or friend. It sounds silly, but practicing the conversation out loud before you have it reveals where you stumble or aren't clear. Get feedback. Adjust your approach.
Expect discomfort. The goal isn't to eliminate the discomfort. The goal is to have the conversation despite the discomfort. You're going to feel anxious. They might get upset. That's normal. Do it anyway.
Review what went well and what didn't. After each difficult conversation, reflect. What felt effective? What would you change next time? You'll get better with practice if you're actually learning from each attempt.
The Long-Term Payoff
Here's what happens when you consistently address issues instead of avoiding them:
Your team respects you more. They know you have standards. They know you'll address problems fairly. The top performers relax because they're not carrying everyone else's weight.
Your job gets easier. Addressing issues early prevents them from escalating. A five-minute conversation about tardiness now beats a termination conversation later.
‍
