You're in week three of the holiday rush. Three people just called out sick. Your best server texted that they have the flu. The forecast says your location will get slammed this weekend. And your schedule has more holes than filled shifts.
This isn't about being unprepared. This is about reality. The 2024-2025 flu season was one of the worst in a decade, with at least 33 million cases and 430,000 hospitalizations. Add that to baseline staffing challenges where 65% of U.S. hotels report ongoing labor shortages and 59% of restaurant operators struggle to fill positions, and you have what crisis management experts would call a compounding emergency.
What defines a staffing crisis (vs. just a bad week)
A crisis is different from a difficult shift. Here's the distinction: if you can solve it by juggling the schedule or calling in one favor, it's a problem. If you're looking at multiple days where you can't safely operate at full capacity, can't meet health and safety requirements, or are about to burn out your remaining staff, it's a crisis.
Research shows that 69% of business leaders experienced a crisis within the last five years, with an average of three crises per organization. The staffing version looks like this: call-outs cascade because overworked staff get sick or quit, customer service suffers because wait times balloon, and remaining employees start weighing whether this job is worth it.
Triage: What you need to do in the next four hours
When you're already in crisis mode, you can't build the perfect system. You need to stop the bleeding first.
Assess what's actually critical. Not what you want to accomplish today. What has to happen for you to operate legally and safely. The U.S. Department of Homeland Security says safety of employees and guests should be the first consideration in crisis response. If you can't staff the kitchen safely, you can't open the kitchen. If you can't cover the floor with enough people to handle emergencies, you scale back.
Some operators resist this. They think about lost revenue or disappointing customers. But here's what crisis management research shows: 25% of businesses fail to reopen within a year after a disaster. Operating unsafely or burning out your core team creates bigger problems than closing early or limiting your menu for a few days.
Make the capacity decision now. Reduce hours, simplify the menu, limit seating, or close a section. Trying to operate at 100% with 60% of your staff doesn't make you a hero. It makes you the manager who drove everyone else to quit.
Call your most reliable people first. Not everyone. Your most reliable three to five people. The ones who have said yes before. 81% of employers are using cross-training and 71% are incentivizing employees to pick up hard-to-fill shifts. Offer premium pay for the next 48-72 hours. Be specific about what you need and when.
Communicate the situation to remaining staff immediately. Not in a panic. In clear terms. "We have five call-outs this week. Here's what we're doing to manage it. Here's what changed about today's plan. Here's how long we expect this to last." 50% of employees say a lack of transparency holds their company back, and that number gets worse during crises.
The 48-hour communication plan
Most managers under-communicate during crises because they're busy solving problems. This is backwards. 78% of employed Americans worry about future pandemics, and 38% say they'd feel unsafe at work following a crisis. Your staff is already worried. Silence makes it worse.
Set up a daily check-in. This can be a quick team message at the start and end of each shift. Three things: what's the current situation, what's the plan for tomorrow, what do people need to know. That's it. Two minutes.
For employees who called out sick, send a brief message: "Hope you feel better. Don't worry about the schedule. When you're ready to come back, let me know and we'll work it out." That's all. You're short-staffed, but treating sick people like they're the problem guarantees you'll be more short-staffed later.
Companies that adjusted by emphasizing off-premises channels and adapting operations showed better resilience during the flu-impacted period. Tell your team what adjustments you're making and why. When people understand the plan, they can execute it.
Cross-deployment: Use the people you have differently
This is not the time to protect territories. If your host can bus tables, they bus tables. If your manager can wash dishes, they wash dishes.
Cross-training employees in different roles adds much-needed flexibility, especially during crises. The challenge is that most places don't cross-train until they need it, and then it's too late. But even minimal cross-training works in a crisis. Ten minutes of "here's how this works" before a shift is better than nothing.
Identify your highest-leverage gaps. If you're short on line cooks, can someone who usually preps step up? If you're short on servers, can your bartender handle a few tables? If you're short on cashiers, can a stocker cover a register?
Some employees will resist. They'll say it's not their job. This is where your communication from earlier matters. You're not asking people to permanently change roles. You're asking for help during a specific crisis period. Be clear about the timeline and the compensation.
What not to do (mistakes that make it worse)
Don't guilt-trip people who called out sick. The 2024-2025 flu season was classified as high severity, with 216 pediatric deaths. This is serious. People who work sick spread it to coworkers and customers, creating more call-outs next week. One manager's brilliant idea to shame someone for calling out can turn into three more infections and a labor board complaint.
Don't promise it will get better soon if you don't know that. False optimism breaks trust faster than honest pessimism. If you don't know when things will stabilize, say that. "I don't know exactly when this will ease up, but here's what we're doing to manage it in the meantime."
Don't try to operate at full capacity with skeleton staff. You're not being tough. You're being reckless. Overworked staff leads to higher employee walkouts and call-outs, creating a snowball effect for staffing problems. The two people who showed up today will quit if you treat them like they need to do the work of six people.
Don't skip breaks or violate labor laws because you're short. The fines are real, the lawsuits are real, and the damage to your reputation is permanent. The retail sector faces approximately $100 billion in annual losses, and only 30% of businesses had a crisis management team when COVID-19 hit. Operating illegally during a crisis doesn't make you a survivor. It makes you a liability.
Engaging employees when everyone is exhausted
Employee engagement sounds like something you worry about during strategic planning meetings, not when you're in the middle of a crisis. But 25% of employees say they'd start looking for a new job after feeling unsafe during a crisis, which means how you handle the next two weeks determines whether you have any staff left after the crisis ends.
Recognition matters more during crises than during normal times. Not pizza parties. Actual recognition. "Thank you for covering that shift on two hours notice. I know that messed up your plans." "You handled that rush with half the usual staff. That wasn't easy." Specific acknowledgment of specific efforts.
Employees need flexibility and autonomy during crises, with some control over their schedule, environment, and tasks. If someone needs to work different hours this week because their kid is sick, make it work. If someone needs to work shorter shifts because they're covering for a sick family member, adjust. The flexibility you show now determines whether they show up for you later.
Ask people what they need. Not in a general way. Specifically. "What would make the next few days more manageable for you?" Sometimes it's schedule changes. Sometimes it's different responsibilities. Sometimes it's just knowing when this might end. If you have slacked on your absence management policies, now is the time to test some out.
The two-week outlook
Crises don't resolve instantly. The CDC reported flu activity typically runs from October through mid-December, with cases potentially lasting into April. If you're dealing with illness-related call-outs during holiday season, you're looking at weeks, not days.
This means you need to shift from emergency response to crisis management. The difference: emergency response is "how do we get through today." Crisis management is "how do we operate sustainably at reduced capacity until this resolves."
Document what you learn. What adjustments worked? Which staff members stepped up? What processes broke down? What would you do differently? You'll face another crisis eventually. Analyzing what went wrong and what worked well after each crisis helps improve preparedness for future challenges.
Build in recovery time. When staff numbers stabilize, don't immediately return to full operations. Give people lighter schedules for a week. Let them catch their breath. Turnover is driven by burnout, inflexible schedules, low wages, and limited advancement opportunities. The whole point of managing through a crisis is to keep your team. Don't lose them in the recovery phase.
When to ask for help (and from whom)
Some managers think asking for help during a crisis shows weakness. This is wrong. Creating a crisis management team with key players from different areas helps identify risks and design solutions based on varied expertise.
Contact your franchisor or corporate office if you're part of a larger organization. They may have resources, additional staff, or operational flexibility you don't know about. Other locations may be able to lend people temporarily.
Call your suppliers. Not to ask for lower prices. To ask for delivery flexibility or extended terms if cash flow is tight because you had to reduce operations. Most suppliers would rather work with you through a crisis than lose you as a customer.
Reach out to other operators in your area who aren't direct competitors. The manager at the breakfast place probably knows someone looking for dinner shifts. The retail store that just scaled back for the season might have people with availability. 84% of retailers planned to hire seasonal workers, down from 96% the previous year, partly due to labor shortages. The labor market is tight everywhere, but personal referrals still work.
What technology actually helps right now
If you're managing schedules on paper or in a group text, you're making the crisis worse. You need to see who's available, who's working, who called out, and who can cover, all in one place.
Tools that let employees see schedules from their phones, request shift swaps, and get automated notifications about changes remove hours of back-and-forth that you don't have time for during a crisis. When someone calls out at 6am, you need to notify everyone who might be able to cover immediately, not spend 45 minutes sending individual texts.
The point isn't technology for its own sake. The point is reducing the communication overhead that eats up management time during crises. Using technology effectively helps minimize the impact of emergencies on operations and customers.
After the crisis: What to document now
When you're in the middle of it, documentation feels like a luxury you can't afford. But you need to capture some basics while they're fresh:
What was the trigger? Was it flu season, was it multiple people quitting at once, was it a perfect storm of several factors?
What was your response? What did you try first? What worked? What didn't?
Who stepped up? Which employees went above and beyond? This information matters for retention and recognition later.
What policies or systems failed? This isn't about blame. It's about identifying gaps. Did your sick leave policy create problems? Did your scheduling system make things harder? Did your communication methods break down?
Every crisis teaches you something and should be added to your playbook for future preparedness. The crisis you're managing right now will inform how you handle the next one, but only if you capture what you learn.
The reality of crisis management
No one opens a restaurant or retail store expecting to manage staffing crises during the busiest season of the year. But 27% of surveyed restaurants name staffing challenges as their main struggle, alongside rising costs. This is the reality of frontline operations.
The difference between businesses that survive crises and businesses that don't isn't that the successful ones avoid problems. It's that they respond faster, communicate better, and make harder decisions sooner. They're willing to scale back when necessary. They're honest with their teams. They treat their remaining staff like the valuable resources they are.
You can't plan your way out of a crisis that's already happening. But you can manage your way through it. Focus on what's critical, communicate constantly, use your people strategically, and document what you learn. The businesses that do this don't just survive crises. They build more resilient teams that are better prepared for whatever comes next.
‍
