What Is PTO Carryover?
Carryover is a policy that allows employees to transfer a portion of their unused paid time off from one year to the next. The opposite of carryover is a "use-it-or-lose-it" policy where unused PTO expires at year-end.
How you handle carryover significantly affects both employee satisfaction and your company's financial liability.
Types of Carryover Policies
Unlimited Carryover
Employees can roll over all unused PTO into the following year with no limit.
Pros:
- Maximum employee flexibility
- Simple to administer
- No year-end rush to use time
Cons:
- Creates large accrued liabilities
- May discourage regular time off
- Employees can accumulate massive balances
Limited Carryover
Employees can carry over a specific amount (e.g., 40 hours or one week) with any excess forfeited.
Pros:
- Balances flexibility with liability management
- Encourages regular time off
- Provides some rollover cushion
Cons:
- Requires tracking and calculations
- Employees may feel penalized for not using time
- Must comply with state restrictions on forfeiture
No Carryover (Use-It-or-Lose-It)
All unused PTO expires at year-end with no rollover allowed.
Pros:
- Minimizes liability
- Strongly encourages time off
- Simple to calculate
Cons:
- Illegal in some states (California, Montana)
- Creates year-end chaos as everyone rushes to use time
- May feel punitive to employees
- Can create coverage problems in December
Conditional Carryover
Some companies allow carryover only under certain conditions:
- Must use carried-over time within first quarter
- Carryover requires manager approval
- Different limits based on tenure
State Law Restrictions
California
Treats accrued vacation as earned wages that cannot be forfeited. Use-it-or-lose-it policies are illegal. You can:
- Cap future accrual once balance reaches a limit
- Require advance notice for taking time
- Deny specific dates for business reasons
You cannot:
- Force forfeiture of earned time
- Implement pure use-it-or-lose-it
Montana
Similar to California, earned vacation cannot be forfeited by policy.
Other States
Most states allow use-it-or-lose-it if:
- The policy is clearly communicated in writing
- Employees receive reasonable notice
- Employees have adequate opportunity to use time
Setting Carryover Limits
If you allow limited carryover, common approaches include:
One Week Maximum
40 hours (one week) is a popular carryover limit. Provides flexibility for a short vacation without creating excessive liability.
Percentage-Based
Allow carryover of 50% of annual accrual:
- 80 hours annual accrual = 40 hours maximum carryover
- Scales automatically with different accrual rates
Tenure-Based Limits
Increase carryover limits with tenure:
- 1-3 years: 40 hours carryover
- 4-6 years: 60 hours carryover
- 7+ years: 80 hours carryover
Rewards loyalty while managing liability.
Communicating Year-End Deadlines
If you have carryover limits or use-it-or-lose-it, employees need advance notice:
Timing
Remind employees about year-end PTO policies:
- At the beginning of Q4 (October)
- Monthly in October, November, December
- Two weeks before year-end
- One week before year-end
Content
Communications should specify:
- Current PTO balance
- How much will be forfeited if unused
- Deadline for using time
- How much can be carried over
- Process for requesting time off
Blackout Periods
If December is a busy time where you can't accommodate everyone taking PTO, you have a problem. Either:
- Start reminders earlier (July/August)
- Increase carryover limits
- Allow partial carryover of December-stranded time
- Reconsider whether use-it-or-lose-it is appropriate
Combining Carryover with Accrual Caps
You can use both an accrual cap and a carryover limit:
Accrual Cap (Ongoing)
Example: 160-hour cap on total accrued balance
- Stops future accrual once reached
- No forfeiture of existing balance
- Can continue accruing after using some time
Year-End Carryover Limit
Example: 40-hour maximum carryover at year-end
- Any hours over 40 are forfeited at year-end (where legal)
- Resets annual accrual to start fresh January 1
- Separate from the ongoing accrual cap
These work together to manage liability while providing flexibility.
Handling Excess PTO at Year-End
When employees have more PTO than can be carried over, options include:
Forfeiture
Where legally allowed, excess time simply disappears at year-end. This requires clear written policy and adequate notice.
Payout
Pay employees for unused time that would otherwise be forfeited. This eliminates the PTO but creates a cash expense.
Extended Deadline
Allow employees to use carried-over time within Q1 of the following year. This provides flexibility without indefinite carryover.
Charity Donation
Some companies allow employees to donate excess PTO to a charity (cash equivalent) rather than forfeiting it. This requires proper tax handling.
PTO Donation Programs
Allow employees to donate excess PTO to a bank that other employees can draw from for catastrophic needs.
Pro-Rated Carryover for New Hires
Employees hired mid-year don't earn a full year's worth of PTO. How should carryover work for them?
Option 1: Pro-Rate Carryover
If they earned 40 hours in their first six months, allow them to carry over up to 40 hours (or whatever percentage of the annual maximum makes sense).
Option 2: Same Limit for Everyone
Apply the same carryover limit regardless of start date. Simple but may feel unfair to long-term employees who earned more time.
Option 3: No Carryover First Year
Require one full year of employment before carryover eligibility. Clear but potentially harsh for employees hired late in the year.
Tax Implications
Accrued PTO as Liability
Unused PTO sits on your balance sheet as a liability. Carryover policies affect the size of this liability for accounting purposes.
Payout Taxation
When you pay out unused PTO, it's taxed as regular wages with all normal withholdings.
Managing Year-End Scheduling
Use-it-or-lose-it and limited carryover create year-end scheduling challenges:
Predictable Crunch
Everyone wants December off. This creates coverage problems.
Solutions
- Spread PTO use throughout the year through reminders
- Implement scheduling software that shows PTO balances when creating schedules
- Require advance requests for December PTO
- Consider first-come, first-served or seniority systems for December
- Offer incentives for taking time during slower periods
Transitioning Between Policies
If you're changing your carryover policy:
From Use-It-or-Lose-It to Carryover
This change is generally positive for employees. Announce it well in advance and clarify:
- When the new policy takes effect
- What happens to current-year PTO
- New carryover limits
From Unlimited to Limited Carryover
This reduction in benefits requires care:
- Provide advance notice (ideally a full year)
- Allow employees time to use excess balances
- Consider grandfathering current balances
- Explain business reasons clearly
Legal Considerations
Some states may consider existing accrued PTO to be earned wages that cannot be taken away. Consult legal counsel before reducing PTO benefits.
Alternative Approaches
Instead of traditional carryover, consider:
Mandatory Minimum Use
Require employees to take at least a certain amount (e.g., 5 days) per year. This ensures regular time off without strict year-end deadlines.
Quarterly Use Requirements
Require employees to take at least some PTO each quarter. Spreads usage throughout the year.
Manager Accountability
Hold managers responsible for ensuring their teams use PTO. Include this in manager performance evaluations.
Automatic Carryover Extension
If an employee couldn't take PTO due to documented business needs, automatically extend their ability to use it into Q1.
Documentation Requirements
Your carryover policy must be in writing in your employee handbook:
Include:
- Whether carryover is allowed
- Maximum amounts that can be carried over
- What happens to excess time
- Year-end deadlines
- When carried-over time must be used
- How carryover interacts with accrual caps
Common Carryover Mistakes
Assuming Use-It-or-Lose-It Is Always Legal
Check your state law before implementing forfeiture provisions.
Inadequate Notice
Surprising employees at year-end that they'll lose time creates resentment and potential legal issues.
Inconsistent Application
Making exceptions for some employees but not others creates discrimination risk.
Ignoring Manager Responsibility
If employees couldn't use PTO because managers denied all requests, forcing forfeiture is particularly problematic.
Not Tracking Properly
Carryover requires accurate tracking of year-end balances and transfers to the new year.
The right carryover policy balances employee needs for flexibility with company interests in managing liability and encouraging regular time off. Whether you allow unlimited rollover, set limits, or require use-it-or-lose-it, the key is clear communication, compliance with state law, and consistent application. Many companies find that limited carryover (allowing 40-80 hours to roll over) provides the best balance.
