Every time you hire an employee, you're participating in the unemployment insurance system. Understanding how this system works helps you budget appropriately, manage workforce changes, and avoid unnecessary costs when employees separate from your business.
The system dates back to the Social Security Act of 1935, created during the Great Depression to help stabilize the economy and support workers during unemployment.
How Employer Unemployment Taxes Work
Employers pay unemployment taxes at both federal and state levels.
Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA): The federal unemployment tax funds administrative costs and provides loans to states when their unemployment funds run low. The FUTA tax rate is 6.0% on the first $7,000 of each employee's wages annually.
However, employers who pay state unemployment taxes on time receive a credit of up to 5.4%, reducing the effective FUTA rate to 0.6%. This means most employers pay $42 per employee annually in FUTA taxes ($7,000 × 0.6%).
You report and pay FUTA taxes quarterly using Form 940.
State Unemployment Tax Act (SUTA): States set their own unemployment tax rates and wage bases. Key factors include:
- Tax Rate: Ranges from under 1% to over 10%, depending on your state and experience rating
- Wage Base: The amount of each employee's wages subject to tax (varies from $7,000 to over $50,000 depending on state)
- Experience Rating: Your claim history affects your rate
According to the U.S. Department of Labor, the national average state unemployment tax rate is approximately 2.7%, but your actual rate depends on multiple factors.
Understanding Your Experience Rating
Your state unemployment insurance tax rate isn't fixed. It's based on your "experience rating," which reflects:
Your Claims History: States track how many former employees have collected unemployment benefits. More claims from your former workers mean higher tax rates. This is why unemployment insurance is sometimes called "experience-rated."
Your Industry: States assign industries to risk classifications. High-turnover industries like restaurants and retail typically face higher base rates than industries with stable employment.
Time in Business: New employers typically pay a standard "new employer rate" for the first few years before their experience rating is established.
Your Reserve Balance: States maintain a conceptual account for each employer. Benefits paid to your former employees reduce your reserve balance. Paying taxes without claims increases it. Your tax rate adjusts based on this balance.
Example: A restaurant that frequently lays off workers during slow seasons will likely have a higher tax rate than a medical practice with stable staffing, even in the same state.
FUTA Credit Reduction States
States that borrow from the federal government to pay unemployment benefits and don't repay the loans on time become "credit reduction states." Employers in these states pay higher FUTA taxes.
The FUTA credit reduces from the normal 5.4% by 0.3% for each year the state has an outstanding loan. Check the IRS credit reduction state list annually.
Who Pays Unemployment Taxes?
Covered Employers: You must pay unemployment taxes if you:
- Paid wages of $1,500 or more in any calendar quarter, or
- Had one or more employees for at least part of a day in 20 or more different weeks
This includes full-time, part-time, and temporary employees.
Exempt Employers: Some organizations are exempt from FUTA (though they may still pay state taxes):
- Certain nonprofit organizations (though they may choose coverage)
- State and local government entities
- Some agricultural employers
Employee Contributions: In Alaska, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania, employees also contribute to state unemployment insurance through payroll deductions.
How Unemployment Claims Affect Your Business
When a former employee files for unemployment benefits:
You'll Receive Notice: Your state sends notification of the claim, typically including:
- The claimant's name and Social Security number
- The reason they gave for separation
- The wages they reported earning from you
- A deadline to respond (often 10 days)
You Can Contest the Claim: Respond promptly if:
- The employee quit without good cause
- You fired them for misconduct
- The information on the claim is incorrect
- They're still employed by you
Your Response Matters: Failing to respond within the deadline may result in benefits being automatically approved, potentially increasing your tax rate.
Documentation Is Critical: Maintain an employee file with thorough records of:
- Written warnings and disciplinary actions
- Attendance records
- Performance reviews or a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP)
- Resignation letters or termination documentation
- Written policies and employee acknowledgments
Managing Unemployment Insurance Costs
Strategic workforce management can help control unemployment insurance costs.
Avoid Unnecessary Layoffs: Consider alternatives like:
- Reduced hours instead of layoffs
- Voluntary time off programs
- Cross-training employees for different roles
- Temporary reassignments
Document Performance Issues: If you need to terminate for cause, ensure you have:
- Written policies clearly communicated to employees
- Documentation of policy violations
- Progressive discipline records
- Clear termination documentation
Respond to All Claims: Even if you think the employee qualifies for benefits, verify the information is accurate. Incorrect wage information can affect your account.
Classify Workers Correctly: Misclassifying employees as independent contractors can result in significant penalties and back taxes if discovered.
Contest Fraudulent Claims: If a former employee claims benefits while working elsewhere or misrepresents their separation, contest the claim immediately.
Voluntary Contributions
Some states allow employers to make voluntary contributions to their unemployment account to improve their experience rating and lower future tax rates. This can make financial sense if:
- A large claim will significantly increase your rate
- The voluntary contribution costs less than the rate increase
- You have stable employment going forward
Consult with your accountant or unemployment tax specialist before making voluntary contributions.
State Unemployment Tax Variations
Unemployment insurance rules vary significantly by state. Examples:
California: High wage base ($7,000) but rates vary widely based on experience (1.5% to 6.2% for most employers in 2024).
Florida: Relatively low rates (0.1% to 5.4%) on first $7,000 of wages.
Washington: High wage base ($68,500 in 2024) but rates vary by industry and experience.
New York: Moderate wage base ($12,500) with rates from 2.1% to 9.9%.
Check your state's unemployment insurance website for current rates and rules.
Reimbursable Employers
Certain employers, primarily nonprofits and government entities, can choose "reimbursable" status instead of paying taxes. Reimbursable employers pay the actual cost of benefits drawn by former employees rather than paying quarterly taxes.
This option can save money for organizations with stable employment but creates cash flow unpredictability when claims occur.
Payroll Service Provider Considerations
If you use a payroll service:
- Verify they're properly calculating and paying unemployment taxes
- Ensure they're responding to unemployment claims on your behalf
- Review your experience rating annually
- Keep copies of all unemployment tax returns
The Hearing Process
If you contest an unemployment claim and are denied, or if the employee appeals an initial denial, you may need to participate in a hearing. This process typically involves:
Preparation: Gather all relevant documentation, identify witnesses, and prepare your testimony.
The Hearing: Usually conducted by phone, an administrative law judge hears testimony from both parties. Present your case clearly and factually.
The Decision: The judge issues a written decision, typically within a few weeks.
Further Appeals: Both parties can appeal the decision through additional levels of review.
Consider consulting an attorney for high-stakes hearings, especially if multiple employees' claims could significantly impact your tax rate.
Best Practices for Employers
Maintain Detailed Records: Keep thorough documentation of:
- Employee policies and acknowledgments
- Attendance and performance
- Disciplinary actions
- Separations (voluntary and involuntary)
Review Claims Promptly: Respond to unemployment notices within deadlines, even if you think the claim is valid.
Monitor Your Tax Rate: Review your state unemployment tax rate annually and understand what's driving it.
Train Managers: Ensure supervisors understand proper termination procedures and documentation requirements.
Consider Separation Agreements: When appropriate, separation agreements can clarify the terms of employment ending.
Budget Appropriately: Factor unemployment taxes into your labor costs when budgeting and pricing.
